The objective of this research was to determine how
the voltage output and temperature of a PV cell would
be affected by letting the photons pass through various
liquid mediums thereby controlling the photonic energy
of light hitting the PV cell. It has been reported that when
a photon hits a piece of silicon, it can be absorbed only
if its energy is higher than the silicon energy band gap,
generating an electron-hole pair that creates electric
current, and sometimes heat (7-10).
The physical properties of the liquid mediums such
as specific heat, density, refractive index, and color,
as well as the purity and crystallinity of the PV cells
(monocrystalline or polycrystalline), might be key factors
in explaining the observed results. The typical specific
heat (J/g*°C) values (at ~25°C) of the mediums were
as follows: DI Water, 4.19; 5% sugar solution, 4.05; 5%
NaCl solution, 3.93; EVOO, 1.97; canola oil, 1.09; air,
1.00 (Table 1).
It was hypothesized that the change in voltage and
temperature trends would be dependent on the specific
heat of the medium, with lower specific heat mediums
producing higher temperatures and lower voltages than
the mediums with higher specific heat. This is due to
the hypothesis that the absorbed photonic energy will
increase the temperature of the mediums (of lower
specific heat) causing the PV cells to heat up. The band
gap energy of semiconductors tends to decrease with
the increase in temperature; this is because with the
increased thermal energy the atomic vibration and the
interatomic spacing increases causing the band gap
energy to decrease. Based on the specific heat values
(Table 1), the transmitted photonic energy that would
be reaching the PV cell surface can be expected as:
Eair > Ecanola oil > EEVOO > E5% NaCl solution > E5% sugar solution > EDI
water, which can cause the temperature increase Δ (+T)
of the medium as ΔTair > ΔTcanola oil > ΔTEVOO > ΔT5% NaCl
solution > ΔT5% sugar solution > ΔTDI water. It can also be predicted
that the voltage decrease Δ (-V) trend could be: ΔVair
> ΔVcanola oil > ΔVEVOO > ΔV5% NaCl solution > ΔV5% sugar solution >
ΔVDI water because research indicates that an increase in
temperature corresponds to a decrease in voltage (8,
9, 10). Although the control (air) has the lowest specific
heat compared to the other mediums studied, it might
also be possible that heat dissipation from the surface
of the PV cell causes some loss of heat whereas the
organic mediums (EVOO, canola oil) act as a heat
storage medium.
If we consider the density of the mediums, the denser mediums will have more mass (as the volume of the liquid
mediums was kept constant, except air) and photons
will have more interactions while travelling through
these mediums before it reaches the PV cell. Table 1
indicates that the densities (g/mL) of EVOO (~0.918) and
canola oil (~0.914) are very similar to the densities of the
aqueous mediums: 5% NaCl solution (~1.036), 5% sugar
solution (~1.015) and water (~0.997). Air has the lowest
density (~0.001) among all mediums tested. We have
conducted further supplementary experiments with a
10% and 15% NaCl solution on PV Cell I, and compared
the corresponding voltage and temperature change data
with that of the 5% NaCl solution, to explore the effect
of density, but no significant impact was observed due
to this density change. Another factor to consider is the
refractive index of the mediums. The refractive index n is
equal to the velocity c of light in empty space, divided by
the velocity v of light in a substance, or n = c/v. Incident
light at the interface of two mediums is either reflected,
absorbed, or transmitted (Figure 1c). The refractive
indices of organic mediums such as EVOO & canola
oil (~1.467) are higher compared to those of aqueous
mediums (~1.333 for water) or air (~1.003) (Table 1).
Due to the higher refractive indices of EVOO/canola
oil, the speed of light is slower in the organic mediums
causing more photon energy absorption, which could
contribute to the temperature increase of the mediums
thereby transferring more heat to the PV cells. Since
canola oil and EVOO retain heat, the temperature of the
photovoltaic cell increases rapidly. The impacts of the
color of the liquid mediums on voltage and temperature
changes were not investigated in this study.
Irrespective of the medium, all the starting voltages
for PV Cell I were similar to each other. Such similarity
in starting voltages, no matter the medium, was also
observed for PV Cell II. It can be inferred that the
amounts of photonic energy going into the PV cells at the
beginning of the experiment were also similar. But due
to a lower specific heat capacity of EVOO and canola
oil compared to aqueous mediums, the PV cells with
the organic mediums experienced greater temperature
increases. Although the specific heat capacity of air is
the lowest, the fact that EVOO had a higher temperature
increase Δ (+T) causing the largest voltage drop Δ (-V),
might be attributed to their higher refractive index values
compared to air. There were two distinct data groups,
1) aqueous (ionic or 5% NaCl & nonionic or 5% sugar)
mediums, and 2) organic hydrocarbon (EVOO, canola
oil) mediums. The organic mediums (EVOO, canola
oil) generated a higher temperature than the aqueous
mediums (DI water, 5% NaCl solution, 5% sugar solution).
Both PV cells showed that the voltage output was
highest when the temperature was lowest (which was
the starting temp ~25oC). It was observed that the
temperature increase of PV Cell I was greater than
the temperature increase of PV Cell II. There could
be a number of possible causes. The surface area of
PV Cell I was less than that of PV Cell II. PV Cell I
was monocrystalline (higher purity), whereas PV Cell II
was a polycrystalline (lower purity) material. Although
unknown, the type of coating materials on the two PV
cells could also be a contributing factor since they were
obtained from different manufacturers.
At the end of the experiment, the resultant voltages
using the aqueous and organic hydrocarbon mediums
were compared with that of the control. Overall, the
performance of the photovoltaic cells (PV Cell I and
PV Cell II) was increased by 5-6% (an estimated value
based on change in voltage Δ (-V) when using aqueous
(ionic and nonionic) mediums compared to air (Table 2a, 3a)). However, it is possible that a number of potential
factors such as measurement error, or the biased effect
of experimental conditions could be impacting the data.
A statistical analysis was performed to better understand
the data generated during the experiments.
Based on the increase in temperature and decrease
in voltage data of the two different photovoltaic cells
used in this study, it was found that the more efficient
mediums were aqueous (ionic/nonionic) and had higher
specific heats and lower refractive indices than the less
efficient mediums, which were organic compounds and
had lower specific heats and higher refractive indices.
This research shows that common household items such
as salt, sugar, and water may be used to increase the
efficiency of photovoltaic cells. This study was important
because although solar energy may have great potential
in today’s world, it cannot be fully utilized unless we
optimize the power output of photovoltaic cells.